By Professor Keith Somerville
In 2022, 87 rhinos were poached for their horns in Namibia, up a staggering worrying 93% on the figure for 2021, when 45 were killed, according to the Ministry of Environment, Forestry and Tourism’s (MEFT) spokesperson, Romeo Muyunda. Most worrying of all, 46 of the rhino poached were in the famous Etosha National Park.
Muyunda said that of those killed 61 were of the rarer black rhino species and 26 were white rhino. Rhino poaching had been increasingly brought under control in Namibia in recent years, after 101 rhinos were killed in 2015. That more than half of those poached last year were killed in in Etosha, where it would be expected that the national park popular with tourists and with government-funded anti-poaching teams would limit poaching is of great concern.
It should be noted that while rhino poaching rose, the Namibian authorities had considerable success in reducing elephant poaching. The press release from MEFT reported that “Elephant poaching figures have decline steeply over the past years from the highest figure of 101 in 2015 to only 4 in 2022.” David Newton, the Programme Office Director for Southern Africa for the international wildlife trade monitoring organisation TRAFFIC told me that people should be careful not to take the rise in rhino poaching out of context by ignoring this major success in reducing other forms of poaching.
Of the 41 rhino killed outside Etosha, 15 were poached on rhino custodianship farms, and 25 on private farms that have small populations of white rhino. The Black Rhino Custodianship Programme started on 14 on April 1993, when the first six rhino were translocated to a privately-owned farm under an agreement signed by the farmer and MEFT. Later in 1993, five more black rhinos were moved to a second private farm. The rhinos came from national parks, as Namibia has no zoo rhinos. All the black rhinos in Namibia are the property of the state, because of their endangered status, while the more numerous white rhinos are not part of the custodianship programme and can be privately owned.
No rhinos were reported to have been killed on the community conservancies, where land is owned and managed by Namibian rural communities, who can get income from safari tourism, hunting and farming to support the residents. Maxi Pia Louis, Director of NACSO (National Association of CBNRM* organisation) which supports the conservancies and represents them, told me on 31 January that the announcement of such an increase in poaching was very sad, though she confirmed that no rhino were known to have been poached on conservancies in 2022, although two suspected poachers had been caught.
Rhino numbers rising despite poaching
Despite the serious rise in rhinos poached in 2022, MEFT last survey at the end of 2021 showed that Namibia’s white rhino population had reached an estimated 1,234 and black rhino numbers were up at 2,156. David Newton of TRAFFIC said that “these are the highest population estimates since 2005” and that despite the disappointing figures from 2022 that the government’s Blue Rhino Task Force and the Namibian police “ have played a significant role in preventing further losses since a peak of 97 rhinos were poached in 2015.” This has included successes in arresting members of poaching gangs before they have killed rhinos – charging them with conspiracy to poach; and a number of poaching syndicates have been dismantled, Newton said.
In June 2022, the Minister of Environment, Forestry and Tourism Pohamba Shifeta announced that MEFT was investigating some of its own employees working in Etosha, after 11 rhinos were found dead there with their horns removed. Shifeta said that these poaching incidents were suspected of being an “inside job”, with some staff working with organised poaching syndicates which were then smuggling the horn out of the country to the markets in China, Vietnam and other far eastern countries.
Although prices for rhino horn have dropped in recent years from a high of £65,000 per kg down to between $25-40,000 per kg in the end-user market in China, Vietnam and elsewhere in East Asia, there is still demand and it is still a lucrative business, with the high prices and undiminished market demand enabling gangs to give large cash incentives (by Namibian earnings’ standards) to those who will assist them.
Problems at Etosha
There has been no word on the extent to which overall rise in poaching can be put down to insiders helping poachers, but there are clearly problems in Etosha, even though in June 2022, Minister Shifeta appointed retired police commander Ndahangwapo Kashihakumwa to lead anti-poaching efforts in the Etosha National Park. According to Shifeta, Kashihakumwa, who currently heads the anti-poaching unit, based in Windhoek, has been deployed with immediate effect as a security adjustment. “We will not relent in ensuring maximum protection of our iconic species in the flagship Etosha National Park and indeed elsewhere in the country,” Shifeta declared at the time.
After the announcement of the overall rise in rhino poaching, Kenneth Uiseb, Deputy Director Wildlife Research and Monitoring at MEFT, told me that, ‘it is a real pity that we continue to see poaching of rhino in the flagship national park. I think maybe more to do with internal systems not functioning effectively. All the resources are pumped into Etosha but still we see cases going up. I believe a change in strategy and involving more the communities neighbouring the park holds the solution to poaching.’
Worrying loss of black rhino but white rhino hit harder across southern Africa
The loss of a large number of black rhinos is particularly worrying. It is listed by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) as Critically Endangered with an estimated 6,195 left in the wild. But white rhino have been hit hard in recent years, especially in South Africa, with numbers dropping to 12,968 – five year ago there thousands more. It is believed that South Africa’s combined black and white rhino population was 15,024, according to the 2022 State of the Rhino Report. There are thought to be 6,195 black rhinos and 15,942 white rhinos left in Africa as a whole, down 6%, from 23,562, since the last IUCN Rhino Specialist Group report in 2017.
On 6 February, the South African Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE), Brenda Creecy, announced that in 2022, the total number of rhinos killed last was 448, down just three rhinos on the 451 killed in 2021. Given the fall in rhinos numbers in South Africa over recent years, this still represents a dangerously high percentage of remaining rhinos – about 3.% of South Africa’s remaining rhinos. Of those killed, 124 were killed in Kruger National Park (home to over a quarter of South African rhinos. This was an impressive drop of 40% on 2021’s figures for the park, and Creecy said no rhinos were killed in other national parks. But reserves and private rhino owners in KwaZulu-Natal were hit very hard, with 244 rhinos killed – 228 in the provinces reserves and 16 on privately owned land. In other parts of South Africa, 70 more rhinos were killed on private land.
*CBNRM – Community-based natural resource management
Professor Keith Somerville is a Senior research Fellow at the Institute of Commonwealth Studies, a member of the Durrell Institute of Conservation and Ecology at the University of Kent and teaches at the Centre for Journalism. He has written a number of books on wildlife and conservation issues such as the ivory trade, human-lion conflict, hyenas, jackals, honey badgers and is currently writing a study of the history of human exploitation and conservation of African rhinos for Pelagic Books.